"With the Straubs, in Too Early, Too Late, we shot outside, a bit all over France. We had about two shots a day and we filmed the same thing from morning to night. The light evolved over the course of the day and, then, they chose while editing. It was a 15 day shoot that could have been done in 3 if someone else had done the scheduling. We had amazing moments, black skies Brittany...But it's a director's demand, who in this case was his own producer."
-William Lubtchansky, 2003
Friday, July 13, 2012
10:15 PM
Ana
"Women directors are a rarity in Portuguese cinema, although there are a couple of first works in post-production at the time of writing. But the filmmaking team of Margarida Cordeiro and António Reis has produced a number of films since Jaime, their 1972 debut. Ana is a marvelous introduction to their surreal vision of the world. Lyrically photographed to capture the atmosphere of the region in which the film is set, Ana is a portrait of a simple, selfless grandmother, filtered through the memory of her grownup granddaughter. Childhood memories, incomplete and half-remembered - the return of a young girl in the middle of a storm, the walk the grandmother takes to a lake - combine to create a timeless, almost liturgical tone. Rejecting the traditional conventions of narrative cinema, Cordeiro and Reis concentrate on incident and form, celebrating the darkness and somberness of the primitive mountain people whose lives are briefly interrupted by a team of ethnographers. 'Let us guard ourselves against looking at the film as if it were a simple ecological requiem advocating a return to nature. The cinema of Reis and Cordeiro has reached a crucial point in which categories like nature, civilization, rural, and urban are condemned to lose their aesthetic relevance. Only knowledge remains. This cinema knows. Ana is a film that has entirely conquered the time and space it evokes.' -João Lopes"
-Piers Handling in the 1990 Festival of Festivals Program
-Piers Handling in the 1990 Festival of Festivals Program
Rohmer on 1.33:1
Wide and Tall
by Eric Rohmer
In issue 31 of the Cahiers, François Truffaut’s famous article, “A Certain Tendency of the French Cinema,” coincided with the collective review of the presentation of the first film in Cinemascope. The magazine’s position was defined not only by what it denounced (content nourished by hackneyed libertarian themes), but by what it highly approved of: a form regenerated by the newest techniques (color, zoom, 3D), but kept in doubt by the nomenklatura of the time.
Among the six writers collaborating in this group, only two, Bazin and Doniol, risked a few timid reservations. The other four - Dorsay, Astruc, Rivette and myself - exhibited an almost delirious enthusiasm; an enthusiasm justified by the long and happy life Cinemascope has known since, and will continue to know, in intimate as well as spectacular films. The paradox, however, is that Rivette and I, its biggest supporters (contrary to Truffaut, Astruc, and Godard at the time), have never, in our films, used the Chretien process. To stick to myself, I’d say that I’ve become a more and more determined adversary of ‘scope in particular and even, in general, of the wide screen. My only 1.66:1 films, aside from my first, The Sign of Leo, are the ones I shot on Super 16. All the others are 1.33:1.
Re-reading this article, I’m alarmed to see that I was praising as “virtues” what I’d now like to denounce as the most insidious vices of contemporary cinema. In a word, I think that, far from favoring directors’ formal inventiveness, widescreen, instead, stifles it. It is, I’m more and more persuaded, if not the only, at least the main culprit for the expressive poverty of the image today.
In believing we were rediscovering the visual dynamism of the silent masterpieces, we were only turning our backs on them, and I’m surprised that widescreen continues to be popular in the profession, without anyone, critics or technicians, daring to bluntly confess that the low ceilings in multiplexes are the real reason behind a commercial rather than an aesthetic choice.
Scope, I said in this article, allowed the film to do away with a certain number of cliches inherited from academic painting. It liberated the frame from the constraints of “composition,” going so far as to render the very notion of “framing” futile. This freedom has revealed itself to be only an illusion: a fact once and for all, inevitably, far from stimulating the directors’ imaginations, it paralyses it, and, thinking they’re escaping stasis, they only fall back into it with renewed force. I don’t think I’m exaggerating by saying that a slightly bigger screen offers a thousand less combinations to filmmakers in the dynamic organization of line, surface and volume than the good, old standard format. It no longer inspires so easily, for example, the frame within a frame constructions in which the “cine-plastic” genius of Griffiths, Murnaus, Langs, Hitchcocks, Renoirs, and a hundred others revealed itself. It weighs down shot/reverse shots, a major element of cinematographic syntax that, even with my love of Welles and Bazin, I’ve never been close to renouncing.
There’s more: “Cinemascope,” I wrote, “finally introduces in our art the only tangible element that escaped it: air, the divine ether of poets.” Now, it is precisely against this lack of air, imposed by current framing, that I do not cease to combat. Because where is the air, if you really look for it? To the left, to the right? No, it is to the top that our eyes looks for it, and it is this upper part that has disappeared. It’s at the top that one breathes, and it is at the top that the poetry is often found! I like that my characters’ heads don’t bump against the top of the frame. I like to show the sky, the trees, the mountains, even the roofs of houses, so much so that I only feel at ease in rooms with high ceilings. It’s a matter of taste, they’ll say. Very well. But, if I miss the upper part of the screen, the lower part is often also lacking for me. The sides aren’t too important: the slightest pan is enough to extend them. On the other hand, knowing that my frames will be “enlarged,” (in fact, “narrowed,” I’d put it) by the projection in most theaters, I have trouble showing with enough “presence” what seems to me to be the most expressive part of the human body (the head, shoulders, and hands) by shots that used to be called “close-up,” that continue, in spite of everything, to make me happy, but that I look for in vain in the films of my younger colleagues. How often have I had to regretfully employ this or that ploy to avoid having my actors’ hands go too low, hands that are often more eloquent than a word or a face! Long live Eisenstein, I’d prefer to proclaim today, who only dreamed of the square screen!
My last film, however, The Lady and the Duke, for the sole purpose of preventing the mangling at the hands of distributors and TV channels, was shot in 16:9. Unfortunately, this format doesn’t exist in movie theaters: its equivalent would be 1.77:1, which projectors can’t do. That’s why the 35mm copy will be printed 1.66:1, to avoid any choice, by the projectionist, of 1.85:1. This policy of the least evil hardly delights me. Shall I say it’s the fault of Cinemascope’s?
Originally published in Cahiers du cinéma, August 2001.
by Eric Rohmer
In issue 31 of the Cahiers, François Truffaut’s famous article, “A Certain Tendency of the French Cinema,” coincided with the collective review of the presentation of the first film in Cinemascope. The magazine’s position was defined not only by what it denounced (content nourished by hackneyed libertarian themes), but by what it highly approved of: a form regenerated by the newest techniques (color, zoom, 3D), but kept in doubt by the nomenklatura of the time.
Among the six writers collaborating in this group, only two, Bazin and Doniol, risked a few timid reservations. The other four - Dorsay, Astruc, Rivette and myself - exhibited an almost delirious enthusiasm; an enthusiasm justified by the long and happy life Cinemascope has known since, and will continue to know, in intimate as well as spectacular films. The paradox, however, is that Rivette and I, its biggest supporters (contrary to Truffaut, Astruc, and Godard at the time), have never, in our films, used the Chretien process. To stick to myself, I’d say that I’ve become a more and more determined adversary of ‘scope in particular and even, in general, of the wide screen. My only 1.66:1 films, aside from my first, The Sign of Leo, are the ones I shot on Super 16. All the others are 1.33:1.
Re-reading this article, I’m alarmed to see that I was praising as “virtues” what I’d now like to denounce as the most insidious vices of contemporary cinema. In a word, I think that, far from favoring directors’ formal inventiveness, widescreen, instead, stifles it. It is, I’m more and more persuaded, if not the only, at least the main culprit for the expressive poverty of the image today.
In believing we were rediscovering the visual dynamism of the silent masterpieces, we were only turning our backs on them, and I’m surprised that widescreen continues to be popular in the profession, without anyone, critics or technicians, daring to bluntly confess that the low ceilings in multiplexes are the real reason behind a commercial rather than an aesthetic choice.
Scope, I said in this article, allowed the film to do away with a certain number of cliches inherited from academic painting. It liberated the frame from the constraints of “composition,” going so far as to render the very notion of “framing” futile. This freedom has revealed itself to be only an illusion: a fact once and for all, inevitably, far from stimulating the directors’ imaginations, it paralyses it, and, thinking they’re escaping stasis, they only fall back into it with renewed force. I don’t think I’m exaggerating by saying that a slightly bigger screen offers a thousand less combinations to filmmakers in the dynamic organization of line, surface and volume than the good, old standard format. It no longer inspires so easily, for example, the frame within a frame constructions in which the “cine-plastic” genius of Griffiths, Murnaus, Langs, Hitchcocks, Renoirs, and a hundred others revealed itself. It weighs down shot/reverse shots, a major element of cinematographic syntax that, even with my love of Welles and Bazin, I’ve never been close to renouncing.
There’s more: “Cinemascope,” I wrote, “finally introduces in our art the only tangible element that escaped it: air, the divine ether of poets.” Now, it is precisely against this lack of air, imposed by current framing, that I do not cease to combat. Because where is the air, if you really look for it? To the left, to the right? No, it is to the top that our eyes looks for it, and it is this upper part that has disappeared. It’s at the top that one breathes, and it is at the top that the poetry is often found! I like that my characters’ heads don’t bump against the top of the frame. I like to show the sky, the trees, the mountains, even the roofs of houses, so much so that I only feel at ease in rooms with high ceilings. It’s a matter of taste, they’ll say. Very well. But, if I miss the upper part of the screen, the lower part is often also lacking for me. The sides aren’t too important: the slightest pan is enough to extend them. On the other hand, knowing that my frames will be “enlarged,” (in fact, “narrowed,” I’d put it) by the projection in most theaters, I have trouble showing with enough “presence” what seems to me to be the most expressive part of the human body (the head, shoulders, and hands) by shots that used to be called “close-up,” that continue, in spite of everything, to make me happy, but that I look for in vain in the films of my younger colleagues. How often have I had to regretfully employ this or that ploy to avoid having my actors’ hands go too low, hands that are often more eloquent than a word or a face! Long live Eisenstein, I’d prefer to proclaim today, who only dreamed of the square screen!
My last film, however, The Lady and the Duke, for the sole purpose of preventing the mangling at the hands of distributors and TV channels, was shot in 16:9. Unfortunately, this format doesn’t exist in movie theaters: its equivalent would be 1.77:1, which projectors can’t do. That’s why the 35mm copy will be printed 1.66:1, to avoid any choice, by the projectionist, of 1.85:1. This policy of the least evil hardly delights me. Shall I say it’s the fault of Cinemascope’s?
Originally published in Cahiers du cinéma, August 2001.
Friday, June 22, 2012
9:59 PM
Moullet on Minnelli (x2)
Designing Woman
Luc Moullet
One explosive evening, a sports reporter meets a ravishing fashion designer. Their friendship is established under rather extraordinary circumstances. Four days later, they get married. In her luxurious New York apartment, the designer (and not the female model, as we are led to believe by a poor translation, plus a bad pun, that a belies the colossal difference between the respective salaries of the two careers)* receives and entertains dressmakers, dancers and writers while, in the room next door, the journalist plays cards with boxers and managers. After falling in love at first sight, they discover their differences: it’s the story of a relationship. Disagreements increase with misunderstandings: she suspects him of infidelity at the very moment when, chased by the corrupt boxing gang he’s fighting in his articles, he’s forced to hide under a false name in a hotel room. After a certain number of quiproquos worthy of Molière, everything ends well, thanks to the intervention of the virtuous dancer while the scores are being settled.
It’s clear that genres are mixed, but the film’s tone fills us in immediately: it’s a comedy. A serious comedy, however, because it seems that Vincente Minnelli, an interesting, but uneven auteur, tried to direct the film of his life by describing certain dramatic and paradoxical aspects - hence the recourse to comedy - of American life, that take on an importance at once eternal and universal.
Is this an exaggeration of the range of a film that was made, above all, to entertain? I don’t believe so because Minnelli expresses himself not by words and theories but rather through extremely subtle brush strokes in the dramatic construction as much as in the arrangement of the lines.
It isn’t necessary, however, to possess a deep knowledge of American sociology to grasp Minnelli’s intentions, all the more so as the difference between this sociology and our own is slim. Two milieus are, then, opposed, modeled after reality: that of the intellectuals or pseudo-intellectuals - from Greenwich Village and Broadway - and that of the sports fans, regulars at Madison Square Garden; two milieus that are absolutely foreign to one another, inheritors of two opposite civilizations.
Minnelli belongs, moreover, to one of these clans: that of the snobs whose position he takes by exploiting certain very personal considerations. Both groups have chosen to live by abstracting reality - either intellectual or physical reality - therefore becoming unfit for their jobs in order to be content. Stupid and defeated boxers, corrupt managers, and vicious gangsters having nothing to envy of artless artists, effeminate dancers, and accomplished gossipers. Their movements are similar, not by what they are (though let’s not forget the extraordinary gag with the henchman who elegantly wipes up his adversary’s blood), but by their baseness, highlighted by the director’s talent. The stunning A Song is Born had already established the connection between the mores of gangsters and library rats.
Our two heroes (and the dancer in the final scene - but her case is special!) partially escape from this fallen world because they love each other and because they are originally from opposite worlds. And the climax explains the film’s structure in a way that I hope you’ll allow me to qualify as brilliant: Lauren Bacall finds happiness because she learns to overcome her fear of physical violence, and she calls for action four times; Gregory Peck is saved from the fight not thanks to the all powerful blows of his moronic bodyguard, but thanks to the ballet routine of the dancer with bizarre movements.
Carried by such a big subject, Minnelli seems to have resolved the formal questions that previously limited his talent. He directs his actors better, without, however, attaining perfection in this area. Lauren Bacall remains the goddess of American cinema, but a better director would have known how to make better use of the possibilities of her skills. Just like the script, the photography and colors are remarkable. The cinematographer John Alton, who does a good job with the very short camera movements, isn’t there for nothing. But what is essential remains the liveliness of the strokes and the economy of means (not on the financial side, the cost being more than a million, but on the dramatic side). Fifty or so out-of-the-ordinary gags - not to mention the effects from the voice over - make up the film’s force (but also its relative weakness because the ideas of the intellectual Minnelli and the distinguished hedonist Minnelli are inspired by the conventions of comedy rather than by the subject’s internal necessities).
In any case, this is a miniature masterpiece of finesse at which you can’t not laugh throughout its two hours.
*The film was released in France as La Femme modèle (The Model Woman).
Originally published in Arts, August 15, 1957.
The Cobweb
by Luc Moullet
Behind the Curtain
Executive Suite - a film entirely consecrated to the narration of a meeting of the board of directors of an important company and an account of the motives of the board members - had a lot of commercial success. John Houseman tried to do it again with this Cobweb: for over two hours the managing members of a psychiatric house compete for power. The reason for their struggle? Will the patterns of the curtains in the boardroom be designed by the doctors or by the patients? Two generations of psychiatrists confront one another. This affair is on the verge of destroying the career and threatening the homes and lives of a dozen characters. This time, the stunning thinness of the subject matter and, especially, the absence of suspense caused the failure with the public.
One might be shocked that the film was directed by Minnelli, classified once and for all among the specialists of musical comedies. Let’s not be mistaken, Minnelli is just as much an intellectual and The Cobweb, just like an earlier attempt, The Bad and the Beautiful which it strongly resembles, carries the mark of his personality. Helped by his screenwriter John Paxton, who is interested in psychological and social problems (cf. The Wild One), Minnelli looked to reconnect to the old tradition of realism - inspired by the French novel from the end of the last century, and the Anglo-Saxon novel that followed it. There is some of William James and Frank Norris in this film. The patients, because they know their faults, sometimes behave more normally than the sane people, who experience multiple distractions. If our psychiatrists appear like the mentally ill it’s because no distinctions can exist between human beings: there are neither good nor bad ones; nor crazy ones, nor sane ones. Everything is relative. As the hero of the film says, as Minnelli told the French press, we have, in our thoughts, good and evil, which are equally reflected in our actions. And we are submitted to this destiny that creates, on this cobweb that is spun, the diverse actions of life; in the same way, our private life cannot escape from the influence of our professional life: all the facts of existence are inseparably linked, whether we want it or not. From this subtle dance of the acts and the characters comes the apparently casual construction. The famous curtains are always there, whatever happens.
Note Minnelli’s taste for troubled feelings: madness interests him a lot, more particularly, the artist’s madness. He himself is a filmmaker on the margins: he is very ambitious, however he prefers to shoot entertainment films. We discover here, in certain moments, a desire for self-justification.
The direction doesn’t keep the promises contained in such a brilliant theme. Relativism has unfortunate influences on the aesthetic. Minnelli considers his characters like typical cases, entities, rather than human beings. The best actors in Hollywood are here. Richard Widmark, Lauren Bacall, Lillian Gish, Susan Strasberg, John Kerr, Charles Boyer are more or less below their capabilities. Only Gloria Grahame, because she doesn’t know how to act, because she is always like she is in real life, contrasts with the hamming of certain actors around her. She walks in a bizarre manner, which makes her sometimes deviate from her path; she takes off her shoes, makes a phone call, frowns with a marvelous naturalness. The scenes with two actors lack nerve (cf. the break between Widmark and L. Bacall). These weaknesses are, however, made tolerable by the diversity and multiplicity of what we are shown. This baroque film leads us to bizarre, messy residences that we didn’t suspect in the New World, to poetic landscapes, natural or recreated in the studio, like the nocturnal river lit by the liveliest colors. More than Minnelli the philosopher, it’s Minnelli the mannerist, the decorator, who brings to his film a certain positive element: the beauty of insignificant details, a rickety telephone, suddenly revelatory lighting, the beauty of a tracking shot, the beauty of strong and precise framing. The color, alone, with its yellowish browns, is rather ugly; but such is the house style at Metro Goldwyn Mayer.
Originally published in Arts, 1955.
Luc Moullet
One explosive evening, a sports reporter meets a ravishing fashion designer. Their friendship is established under rather extraordinary circumstances. Four days later, they get married. In her luxurious New York apartment, the designer (and not the female model, as we are led to believe by a poor translation, plus a bad pun, that a belies the colossal difference between the respective salaries of the two careers)* receives and entertains dressmakers, dancers and writers while, in the room next door, the journalist plays cards with boxers and managers. After falling in love at first sight, they discover their differences: it’s the story of a relationship. Disagreements increase with misunderstandings: she suspects him of infidelity at the very moment when, chased by the corrupt boxing gang he’s fighting in his articles, he’s forced to hide under a false name in a hotel room. After a certain number of quiproquos worthy of Molière, everything ends well, thanks to the intervention of the virtuous dancer while the scores are being settled.
It’s clear that genres are mixed, but the film’s tone fills us in immediately: it’s a comedy. A serious comedy, however, because it seems that Vincente Minnelli, an interesting, but uneven auteur, tried to direct the film of his life by describing certain dramatic and paradoxical aspects - hence the recourse to comedy - of American life, that take on an importance at once eternal and universal.
Is this an exaggeration of the range of a film that was made, above all, to entertain? I don’t believe so because Minnelli expresses himself not by words and theories but rather through extremely subtle brush strokes in the dramatic construction as much as in the arrangement of the lines.
It isn’t necessary, however, to possess a deep knowledge of American sociology to grasp Minnelli’s intentions, all the more so as the difference between this sociology and our own is slim. Two milieus are, then, opposed, modeled after reality: that of the intellectuals or pseudo-intellectuals - from Greenwich Village and Broadway - and that of the sports fans, regulars at Madison Square Garden; two milieus that are absolutely foreign to one another, inheritors of two opposite civilizations.
Minnelli belongs, moreover, to one of these clans: that of the snobs whose position he takes by exploiting certain very personal considerations. Both groups have chosen to live by abstracting reality - either intellectual or physical reality - therefore becoming unfit for their jobs in order to be content. Stupid and defeated boxers, corrupt managers, and vicious gangsters having nothing to envy of artless artists, effeminate dancers, and accomplished gossipers. Their movements are similar, not by what they are (though let’s not forget the extraordinary gag with the henchman who elegantly wipes up his adversary’s blood), but by their baseness, highlighted by the director’s talent. The stunning A Song is Born had already established the connection between the mores of gangsters and library rats.
Our two heroes (and the dancer in the final scene - but her case is special!) partially escape from this fallen world because they love each other and because they are originally from opposite worlds. And the climax explains the film’s structure in a way that I hope you’ll allow me to qualify as brilliant: Lauren Bacall finds happiness because she learns to overcome her fear of physical violence, and she calls for action four times; Gregory Peck is saved from the fight not thanks to the all powerful blows of his moronic bodyguard, but thanks to the ballet routine of the dancer with bizarre movements.
Carried by such a big subject, Minnelli seems to have resolved the formal questions that previously limited his talent. He directs his actors better, without, however, attaining perfection in this area. Lauren Bacall remains the goddess of American cinema, but a better director would have known how to make better use of the possibilities of her skills. Just like the script, the photography and colors are remarkable. The cinematographer John Alton, who does a good job with the very short camera movements, isn’t there for nothing. But what is essential remains the liveliness of the strokes and the economy of means (not on the financial side, the cost being more than a million, but on the dramatic side). Fifty or so out-of-the-ordinary gags - not to mention the effects from the voice over - make up the film’s force (but also its relative weakness because the ideas of the intellectual Minnelli and the distinguished hedonist Minnelli are inspired by the conventions of comedy rather than by the subject’s internal necessities).
In any case, this is a miniature masterpiece of finesse at which you can’t not laugh throughout its two hours.
*The film was released in France as La Femme modèle (The Model Woman).
Originally published in Arts, August 15, 1957.
The Cobweb
by Luc Moullet
Behind the Curtain
Executive Suite - a film entirely consecrated to the narration of a meeting of the board of directors of an important company and an account of the motives of the board members - had a lot of commercial success. John Houseman tried to do it again with this Cobweb: for over two hours the managing members of a psychiatric house compete for power. The reason for their struggle? Will the patterns of the curtains in the boardroom be designed by the doctors or by the patients? Two generations of psychiatrists confront one another. This affair is on the verge of destroying the career and threatening the homes and lives of a dozen characters. This time, the stunning thinness of the subject matter and, especially, the absence of suspense caused the failure with the public.
One might be shocked that the film was directed by Minnelli, classified once and for all among the specialists of musical comedies. Let’s not be mistaken, Minnelli is just as much an intellectual and The Cobweb, just like an earlier attempt, The Bad and the Beautiful which it strongly resembles, carries the mark of his personality. Helped by his screenwriter John Paxton, who is interested in psychological and social problems (cf. The Wild One), Minnelli looked to reconnect to the old tradition of realism - inspired by the French novel from the end of the last century, and the Anglo-Saxon novel that followed it. There is some of William James and Frank Norris in this film. The patients, because they know their faults, sometimes behave more normally than the sane people, who experience multiple distractions. If our psychiatrists appear like the mentally ill it’s because no distinctions can exist between human beings: there are neither good nor bad ones; nor crazy ones, nor sane ones. Everything is relative. As the hero of the film says, as Minnelli told the French press, we have, in our thoughts, good and evil, which are equally reflected in our actions. And we are submitted to this destiny that creates, on this cobweb that is spun, the diverse actions of life; in the same way, our private life cannot escape from the influence of our professional life: all the facts of existence are inseparably linked, whether we want it or not. From this subtle dance of the acts and the characters comes the apparently casual construction. The famous curtains are always there, whatever happens.
Note Minnelli’s taste for troubled feelings: madness interests him a lot, more particularly, the artist’s madness. He himself is a filmmaker on the margins: he is very ambitious, however he prefers to shoot entertainment films. We discover here, in certain moments, a desire for self-justification.
The direction doesn’t keep the promises contained in such a brilliant theme. Relativism has unfortunate influences on the aesthetic. Minnelli considers his characters like typical cases, entities, rather than human beings. The best actors in Hollywood are here. Richard Widmark, Lauren Bacall, Lillian Gish, Susan Strasberg, John Kerr, Charles Boyer are more or less below their capabilities. Only Gloria Grahame, because she doesn’t know how to act, because she is always like she is in real life, contrasts with the hamming of certain actors around her. She walks in a bizarre manner, which makes her sometimes deviate from her path; she takes off her shoes, makes a phone call, frowns with a marvelous naturalness. The scenes with two actors lack nerve (cf. the break between Widmark and L. Bacall). These weaknesses are, however, made tolerable by the diversity and multiplicity of what we are shown. This baroque film leads us to bizarre, messy residences that we didn’t suspect in the New World, to poetic landscapes, natural or recreated in the studio, like the nocturnal river lit by the liveliest colors. More than Minnelli the philosopher, it’s Minnelli the mannerist, the decorator, who brings to his film a certain positive element: the beauty of insignificant details, a rickety telephone, suddenly revelatory lighting, the beauty of a tracking shot, the beauty of strong and precise framing. The color, alone, with its yellowish browns, is rather ugly; but such is the house style at Metro Goldwyn Mayer.
Originally published in Arts, 1955.
Jusqu'à la victoire/Ici et Aillieurs
-->
Thus, it was sometimes more a matter of confirming an established plan on location than going to discover a country and a people. According to the Dziga Vertov group, revolutionary cinema is done at this cost: structure and manufacturing precede the recording of reality. Marco attests to this: “We went there to confirm a plan, not to discover a situation that we didn’t know.” This obviously lead to some misunderstandings, like the time when, in a Fedayeen training camp in southern Jordan, Godard and Gorin asked Palestinian fighters to recite an extract from Mao’s Little Red Book that they didn’t know anything about, which they did while laughing wildly behind their keffiyehs. Another time, returning from a mission, Godard waited for the fedayeens to propose to them a “critique and self-critique” meeting, which the Palestinians did not understand, setting themselves to talking in Arab in the background while in the foreground an interpreter continued in English with conventional Fatah slogans. If they had a revolutionary manner – at this Godard started regularly wearing military fatigues, as reported by a journalist from L’Express who went to meet them in Amman in 1970 –, the two French filmmakers were sometimes a bit lost in an unknown territory.
Pages 467-473 of Antoine de Baecque's GODARD BIOGRAPHIE on the making of Godard and Gorin's Jusqu'à la victoire.
In February 1969, Yasser Arafat is elected president of the
PLO – the Palestinian Liberation Organization, created in 1964 – and his party,
the Fatah, becomes the majority leader of it.
In this frame, the first films of the Palestinian cinema appear since a
film unit is founded by the Fatah in Amman, Jordan under the aegis of three
pioneers, Hany Jawhariyya, Sulafa Jadallah and Mustapha Abu Ali, who made, for
example, The Burnt Land in 1968 and No to the Defeatist Solution in 1969,
the first militant films against the Israeli attacks and the Rogers Plan. It is also by the intermediary of the Fatah,
at least due to its financial, logistical, and ideological support, that a
Western “anti-Zionist cinema” is born with films such as Jean-Pierre Olivier de
Sardan’s Palestine vaincra, the
current events series Palestine made
by French reporter Paul-Louis Soulier, and
the medium-length film Biladi in 1969
and 1970, an inspired and lyrical but equally poetic and sometimes disenchanted
piece of reporting about the Palestinian people directed by Francis Reusser (a
young Swiss filmmaker of the extreme left).
It is in this political and cinematic context that Godard
and Gorin’s project, entitled Until
Victory, is born. Contacted by the
Arab League, via Hany Jawhariyya (the “official” filmmaker of the Fatah),
Godard received a commission in 1969, for about 6,000 dollars, and an
invitation in good and due form to be able to shoot in the Palestinian camps in
Jordan, the West Bank, and Lebanon, under the protection of the Fatah, who also
put guides and interpreters at his disposal.
Godard obtained supplemental financing from Jacques Perrin (the
actor-producer gave 20,000 francs), German and Dutch TV stations (8,000 and
5,000 dollars respectively), and the usual Claude Nedjar (8,000), or a total of
about 70,000 francs.
Before leaving, Godard, Gorin and Marco drew up the “outline
of a Palestinian film commissioned by El Fatah” that summed up in several
slogans their still imprecise intentions: “What happened to the American Indians
can not happen to the Palestinians. The
armed struggle is not a military adventure; it is the struggle of the
people. Palestinian face and Arab heart. War of national liberation = social
struggle. First create unity (El
Fatah).” This preparatory document ends
with several verses from Mahmoud Darwish’s poem Identity Card, a veritable Palestinian hymn published in the
collection Leaves of Olives in 1964:
“Record!
I am
an Arab
You
have stolen the orchards of my ancestors
And
the land which I cultivated
Along
with my children
And
you left nothing for us
Except
for these rocks.
So
will the State take them
As
it has been said!?
Therefore!
Record
on the top of the first page:
I do
not hate people
Nor
do I encroach
But
if I become hungry
The
usurper's flesh will be my food
Beware…
Beware…
Of
my hunger
And
my anger!”
Next,
Godard and Gorin worked non-stop to put together a precise storyboard about
what they wished to film in Palestine.
This takes the shape of a big spiral-bound notebook where most of the
shots of the future film are drawn, often sequences of an allegorical kind or
short cautionary sketches, accompanied by slogans, words and emblematic
phrases, including notes about movements, colors, and references to certain
texts. The explicit goal of the film as
prepared in Paris consisted in “understanding the thought and working methods
of the Palestinian revolution”: “As Frenchmen, we have conceived the film as a
film on the Arabs that was never made during the Algerian War.” Godard seemed to want to make up for the time
lost ten years before when he made Le
Petit soldat instead of a film supporting the NLF.
The three Vertovians left for Jordan for the first time at
the end of November 1969, and made a total of six trips to the Middle East
until the following August, regularly punctuated by return trips to Paris or
trips to other parts of the world – especially for Godard who was often called
back to France, for example, to attempt to deal with the crisis that effected
his relationship with Anne Wiazemsky.
Elias Sanbar, a young intellectual and militant French-speaking
Palestinian called from Paris by the Fatah to serve as a guide and interpreter
recounted his visits and the shoot in a beautiful article published in Trafic.
The future editor-in-chief of the Revue
d’études palestiniennes returned to Amman, the capital of Jordan,
in the beginning of March 1970 at the request of Mahmoud Hamchari (the
Palestinian leader in Paris), and met the “three Frenchmen,” including Godard
who, during the first meeting at the Continental Hotel, arrived walking on his
hands to the amazement of the young Palestinian militants. Setting off on a location scout towards the
Jordan Rift Valley in a Land Rover, Sanbar quickly perceived the degree of the
film’s preparation in the two French filmmakers’ heads and notebook. The film was already partially done “on
paper”: “Throughout the trip,” writes Sanbar, “Godard did not cease to look at
his notes, to add comments to them, to eliminate passages with the help of
three different colored markers. This
manner of preparing the shoot was maintained for the length of time that work
on the film lasted. Godard wrote a lot,
with a certain jubilation that seemed to abandon him during the shooting to be
replaced by a certain detachment. The
scenes were thought out in the smallest details before being filmed. At the beginning, I had the feeling – with
everything being discussed, systematized, written and planned – that the film
was a kind of pre-established succession of empty cases that we had the task of
methodically refilling. […] So well that when something was happened and
we were saying to him, ‘Come film this,’ he would respond: ‘I don’t need it for
the film…’”
Thus, it was sometimes more a matter of confirming an established plan on location than going to discover a country and a people. According to the Dziga Vertov group, revolutionary cinema is done at this cost: structure and manufacturing precede the recording of reality. Marco attests to this: “We went there to confirm a plan, not to discover a situation that we didn’t know.” This obviously lead to some misunderstandings, like the time when, in a Fedayeen training camp in southern Jordan, Godard and Gorin asked Palestinian fighters to recite an extract from Mao’s Little Red Book that they didn’t know anything about, which they did while laughing wildly behind their keffiyehs. Another time, returning from a mission, Godard waited for the fedayeens to propose to them a “critique and self-critique” meeting, which the Palestinians did not understand, setting themselves to talking in Arab in the background while in the foreground an interpreter continued in English with conventional Fatah slogans. If they had a revolutionary manner – at this Godard started regularly wearing military fatigues, as reported by a journalist from L’Express who went to meet them in Amman in 1970 –, the two French filmmakers were sometimes a bit lost in an unknown territory.
Neither Godard, Gorin, or Marco spoke or understood Arabic,
and on both sides the incomprehension mounted.
Gorin recounted this often delicate dialogue: “It was a long difficult
gestation. We had drawings, outlines in
black and red, plans, interruptions. We
showed them to the Palestinians who didn’t understand. We didn’t understand any of the
language. The translators translated as
they wished, generally by slogans they knew by heart. This sometimes became comical, everything
that was said to us was summed up as “We will fight until victory,” so often that
we ended up laughing. In a pathetic way
it confirmed our title. For us, it
rather quickly became a silent film, or rather a musical.” But Elias Sanbar describes just as much the
opposite phenomenon, when the environment made the filmmakers rethink their
judgement and to “remake the film” in another way. Godard returned to his ultra-quick “thief”
and “disrupter” of reality reflexes, which greatly impressed his Palestinian
companion. “Often, from the moment of
return from meetings or filming, and the immediate viewing of the images that
we had just “brought back” thanks to heavy video equipment, a confrontation
began between the pre-existing text and the images that had just been
shot. It ended up most of the time with
re-writing and a new request to shoot the same scene, to the great astonishment
of the Palestinian representatives. Over
the course of days and weeks, Godard appeared to me more and more of a terrific
destabilizing force. […] There is something very playful about working with
him, but mixed with a form of permanent irritation, because hardly had things
been constructed with his meticulous care that he pressed himself to
deconstruct them with care to disrupt the gaze that you can bring to the
reality that surrounds you.”
The shoot, which actually began in March 1970, to continue with
breaks until August, was one of Godard’s longest, and he returned to Paris with
more than 40 hours of rushes. Certain things had been impossible to shoot
which the Frenchmen had not foreseen. “When the women were teaching
themselves to read and write in the Palestinian camps,” remembers Gorin, “the
presence of men bothered them, so they refused to be filmed and we didn’t
understand why.” Likewise, Jean-Pierre Gorin being Jewish, some other
doors were closed to them, notably in the Fatah training camps. Other
events fortunately jostled the foreseen plan, notably the meetings with the
combatants, animated and joyful in the middle of the dangers of the desert,
like in Ghawr al-Safi, in southern Jordan, coming back from which Godard
confided to Sanbar, “You know, every people, every revolution possesses a
particular characteristic, like an element of its own identity. For the
Vietnamese, it was hard labor; for the Cubans, it was dance, and for you, it’s
certainly laughter.”
Godard also wanted to meet and
film the Palestinian leader. He secured a meeting. The filmmaker
posed two questions to Yasser Arafat, the first about the concentration camps.
“I asked him if the origins of the Palestinians’ difficulties had
something to do with the concentration camps. He said to me, ‘No, that’s
their story, the Germans and the Jews.’ And I said, ‘Not exactly, you
know that in the camps, when a Jewish prisoner was very weak, close to death,
they called him Muslim.’ And he responded, ‘So?’ I said,
‘You know, they could have called them black or an entirely different
name, but no, they said Muslim, and that shows that there is a
relationship, a direct relationship between the Palestinians’ difficulties and
the concentration camps.” The second question was very short, “what is
the future of the Palestinian revolution?” And Arafat’s response was even
shorter, “I have to think about it, come back tomorrow.” Godard finished
the story, “He never came back. At least he was honest.” In
mid-July 1970, Armand Marco had to return to France after having badly sprained
his knee. The shoot neared its end, Gorin returned to Paris, leaving
Godard and Sanbar alone in Amman.
At the beginning of the month of
August 1970, Kamal Adwan, Fatah’s information manager, asked Godard to go film
Palestinian dancers. As Elias Sanbar recounts, “Kamal greeted us and, a
very unusual thing for Palestinians, went directly into the subject, ‘Tell your
friend that a Palestinian folklore troupe just arrived in Cairo and that I want
you to leave tomorrow to film the show.’ I transmitted the request,
smoothing out the angles with paraphrased bits, I didn’t wanted Godard to be
hurt. Godard immediately told me and with a stubborn tone, ‘Tell him that
his dance story is entirely stupid. I won’t go to Cairo.’ [...] Kamal
looked Godard straight in the eye and said, ‘And I think you have to go film
this troupe,’ to which Godard responded again, ‘I won’t go to Cairo...’ I was
allowed two or three repetitions of this exchange before Kamal got up and said,
‘Go to your hotel and wait for instructions.’...” Consigned and forgotten
in their rooms at the Amman Continental, Godard and Sanbar waited a good week
before discretely leaving for Tyre in south Lebanon, where the filmmaker left a
part of his video equipment with the local Fatah director, a movie fan and
amateur filmmaker. Then they stayed at the translator’s mother’s house in
a village in the Lebanese mountains, before going to Beirut where they met with
militant Palestinians from the information section. Godard returned to
Paris on August 21, 1970, not without leaving Elias Sanbar, who had become a
close friend, the ten volumes of Brecht’s complete poetry.
Gorin and Godard, upon their
return to Paris, put in a notebook the list of “filmed images,” notably:
“Fedayeen march. Darwish’s poem ‘I Resist’ in the ruins of Karameh.
Militia construction. Meeting in the south. Militia in the
cave. Two women at typewriters. Militia with machine guns.
Preparations, leaving, operation. Dispensary. Ashbal-Zaharat
training. Abou Hassan conference. Peasant militia text. Doctor
text. Women reading Abou Hassan text. Democratic Front school.
“Grassroots organisation” discussion and self-critique. Two AK-47s
firing. Safi song. Militia training, with flag. Crowd of
children. Fedayeen camouflage. Directors: Abou Latov, Abou Ayad, Abou
Daoud, Abou Hassan.” Or, an enormous amount of rushes to view and texts
to decipher and translate. The work appeared like it will be long, but
Godard and Gorin were happy about one thing: Armand Marco’s cinematography was
beautiful and rarely had the filmmaker found himself with material so dense and
of such a large quantity, in spite of the numerous misunderstandings of an
overly prepared shoot in an unknown land. It is no doubt that it is the quantity,
quality and cryptic character of this film material that explains in part the
difficulty of transforming it into a film.
Jean-Luc Godard and Jean-Pierre
Gorin – barricaded in their editing studio on Avenue du Maine, completely
closed off because they were afraid, at this moment of high tensions in the
Middle East, of being victims of agents from Mossad, militants from Betar, or
Jordanian secret service agents – will not manage to finish Until Victory.
Several reasons may explain the abandonment of the project. First,
the ambiguity between two irreconcilable positions - felt on location while
shooting - had not been resolved. Was it a propaganda film for the Fatah
or a political essay, and thus a critique, on the methods of the Palestinian
resistance? The Dziga Vertov group refused to create a militant film as
they had been commissioned. This paradox was not new and re-surged with Until
Victory as Jean-Henri Roger said, “It wasn’t a question of produce or not
producing propaganda images. Now, when you find yourself in front of
political apparatuses that is the only kind of request. The PLO
wanted Jean-Luc Godard, the great, world renowned filmmaker, to make a ‘progressive
and democratic’ film that told the world that the Palestinians were
suffering and that the PLO was right.”
Moreover, several weeks after
Gorin’s and then Godard’s departure from Jordan, a fair number of fighters,
militants, and Palestinian leaders who were in the film were killed during the
Black September massacres, when King Hussein decided to liquidate the
Palestinian resistance and send its remains to the refugee camps in Amman.
25,000 were counted dead. Gorin said he felt the tension
mounting, “the arming of the Jordanians by the Americans,” and the rivalry
sharpen between the Jordanian power and its two opponents which were the Fatah
and the Democratic Front for the Liberation of Palestine. Following these
massacres, the Palestinian situation changed completely. Decapitated and
decimated, the liberation movement no longer thought of “victory,” but thought
instead about rearming and regrouping. This explosion of internal violence
in the Arab camp began to frustrate the Until Victory project, as if the
armed struggle, that occupied the film, had been displaced to the very heart of
the Palestinian camp. Godard and Gorin were profoundly shaken by Black
September. Additionally, the idea of showing the rough cut of the film to
the Palestinian militants, dear to the filmmakers, that they had filmed became
impossible, since the majority of them had died and going back to the location
was problematic. Until victory
thus lost its first audience. Godard and Gorin, orphaned, conceived of
three or four different versions of the film, but none satisfied them.
The later recognized this in an interview with American critics, “There’s
still the Palestinian film, that changed a lot. It’s in its third or
fourth version and now it is going to have to be done in another way. We
can no longer make a film about Palestine because the situation there has
changed so radically that, as a result, it will be a film about how to film
history.” Until Victory was overtaken by the dramatic story of the
people of whom it wanted to offer a revolutionary portrait.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


